Physicists are saying to nature "Surprise me, tell me something more about yourself, but do it while following these rules." (If you were asked for the same question, how much would you tell?) And the surprise that nature gives us, the gift of new knowledge - it then becomes "ours," and gives us new power over nature. At least one writer compares scientific experiment to "putting nature on the rack" to force her to divulge her secrets. It is possible to pursue the scientific endeavour in a way that really respects and treasures the nature that is being studied, but for many researchers the attitude has been more a pursuit of dominance, an effort to conquer nature and bend her to our will. If the truth be told all too many individual scientists, like so many other hard workers in today's competitive economy, are obsessed with their own personal success, and nature is their tool for getting there. This tendency is magnified by the current alignment between the scientific community and the power centers of government, business, consumer markets, and military machines.
If there is an analogy between love and the experimentalist's attentive observation of the world (as I claimed earlier in this blog), this analogy has its limits, because all too often the end result has been something that looks a lot more like rape than like peaceful harmony. In the small it looks like plastic wrappers in the trash and children and old people alike wasting away in front of TVs; in the large it looks like a planet whose species are devastated, whose hidden treasures are excavated, pumped, and burned, and whose peoples destroy and enslave each other with the most advanced technologies.
Is this tendency for science to result in the abuse of persons and of the environment something external to physics (as many scientists would like to think) or built into physics from its very foundations?
Showing posts with label scientific experiment. Show all posts
Showing posts with label scientific experiment. Show all posts
Thursday, February 28, 2008
Control Over Experiments - Why Repeat?
You might conclude that running an experiment for the second or third time is boring and produces no new information. That's not so. The only way to figure out whether a particular result really is scientific truth is by repeating experiments, in different places and times, with different equipment and measurement devices, under the guidance of different scientists. But beyond the effort of obtaining scientific "certainty" one may also find out new things. It is always possible that the original experiment was influenced by something that the experimentalist was not aware of, so repeating the experiment may reveal the need for more a more precise statement of the experimental set up. (For instance, minute impurities in water can cause large changes in its resistance to electricity. Pure water is not a good conductor. If two measurements of water's conductivity give different values, this may reflect need for more control over the water's impurities rather than a fundamental scientific inacuracy.) Repeating an experiment may bring these set up issues to light, as one goes through a trial and error struggle to reproduce the original result.
In addition, even if the first experiment's outcome was observed correctly, the mechanisms which produced that outcome may have been misunderstood. Repetition with differently constructed experimental setups, or with a variety of measuring methods, gives evidence for a robust understanding of how the experiment works. Conversely, a different result obtained using slightly different equipment may be the first step toward a deeper understanding of what's going on.
In addition, even if the first experiment's outcome was observed correctly, the mechanisms which produced that outcome may have been misunderstood. Repetition with differently constructed experimental setups, or with a variety of measuring methods, gives evidence for a robust understanding of how the experiment works. Conversely, a different result obtained using slightly different equipment may be the first step toward a deeper understanding of what's going on.
Control Over Experiments and Scientific Truth
Earlier I said that experiments involve careful observation of nature, trying to see it very accurately, with the overall hope of learning something new and surprising. I also emphasized the fact that nature is external to oneself and not totally under one's own power. Therefore it may seem incongruous that physicists seek experiments that can be repeated at will, under total control.
On one level there is no contradiction: we create experiments that can be repeated - however the first time we run the experiment we are in suspense about what will actually be observed. The certainty and repeatability is in our preparation of the experiment; the surprise is in the experiment's actual outcome, the details or whole of which may be different than expected.
The point of having totally repeatable control over an experiment is that the experiment's outcome should be exactly the same every time it is performed. Once an experiment is done once, the surprises should be over, and further repetitions of the experiment only serve to verify the scientific truth of the original result. In fact the only "truth" that physicists care to recognize while acting as physicists is those observations that can be repeated experimentally, as well as any mathematical techniques whose predictions have been repeatedly checked experimentally. If you repeat an experiment and obtain a different result than what was originally found, this casts doubt on whether the original result actually was "scientific truth."
For instance, the failure by many to reproduce cold fusion is said to have "discredited" the original experiment which observed cold fusion, leading most physicists to think that probably cold fusion did not occur even in the original experiment. Of course it is possible that fusion actually occurred the first time but not other times - but even if this were true it would not be a "scientific truth," simply because it can not be reproduced on demand by everyone. The only ways to establish the truth or falsity of this possibility would be similar to the procedures used when investigating and judging a crime - collection of historical evidence about the equipment that was used in the first cold fusion experiment and the data that was obtained, rethinking how to interpret all that was observed, judgments about the trustworthiness of the scientists, etc. There may also be reasoning based on currently accepted ideas of how the universe works, and efforts to establish whether or not these ideas indicate any possible way that fusion might have happened in the first cold fusion experiment. In any case, the result of this sort of process would not be "scientific truth," simply because it would be confining itself to a particular time, place, and set of scientists and observations. Physics does not deny the the possibility of truths of a particular, non-repeatable nature - the shape of a particular rock, the sound of a specific person's voice, etc. - but neither does it pay much attention to these things.
On one level there is no contradiction: we create experiments that can be repeated - however the first time we run the experiment we are in suspense about what will actually be observed. The certainty and repeatability is in our preparation of the experiment; the surprise is in the experiment's actual outcome, the details or whole of which may be different than expected.
The point of having totally repeatable control over an experiment is that the experiment's outcome should be exactly the same every time it is performed. Once an experiment is done once, the surprises should be over, and further repetitions of the experiment only serve to verify the scientific truth of the original result. In fact the only "truth" that physicists care to recognize while acting as physicists is those observations that can be repeated experimentally, as well as any mathematical techniques whose predictions have been repeatedly checked experimentally. If you repeat an experiment and obtain a different result than what was originally found, this casts doubt on whether the original result actually was "scientific truth."
For instance, the failure by many to reproduce cold fusion is said to have "discredited" the original experiment which observed cold fusion, leading most physicists to think that probably cold fusion did not occur even in the original experiment. Of course it is possible that fusion actually occurred the first time but not other times - but even if this were true it would not be a "scientific truth," simply because it can not be reproduced on demand by everyone. The only ways to establish the truth or falsity of this possibility would be similar to the procedures used when investigating and judging a crime - collection of historical evidence about the equipment that was used in the first cold fusion experiment and the data that was obtained, rethinking how to interpret all that was observed, judgments about the trustworthiness of the scientists, etc. There may also be reasoning based on currently accepted ideas of how the universe works, and efforts to establish whether or not these ideas indicate any possible way that fusion might have happened in the first cold fusion experiment. In any case, the result of this sort of process would not be "scientific truth," simply because it would be confining itself to a particular time, place, and set of scientists and observations. Physics does not deny the the possibility of truths of a particular, non-repeatable nature - the shape of a particular rock, the sound of a specific person's voice, etc. - but neither does it pay much attention to these things.
Sunday, February 17, 2008
Control Over Experiments - Hard Sciences vs. Soft Science
It is precisely this repeatability by anybody, at any time, as many times as desired, and under perfect control, that physicists prize in their experiments and consider to be the hallmark of "scientific truth." Conversely, if something does not meet these standards, then we refuse to think about it or discuss it, at least not as physics per se. We leave these questions to other disciplines, and we uses the words "hard" vs. "soft" to describe how well a discipline conforms to the scientific ideals of repeatability and control, with physics on the "hard" end of the spectrum. ("Hard" vs. "soft" has nothing to do with how difficult the fields actually are.) For instance, astronomy has the problem that the stars are not under our control and we can not make them repeat their behavior; however if ten astronomers look at the same star at ten different times they will almost certainly see the same thing, which is a sort of repeatability. There is also a statistical repeatability in astronomy: picking a thousand stars at random, you always find roughly the same number of red giants, white dwarfs, Sun-type stars, etc. So astronomy is not as "hard" a science as physics; we can also say that it is a "softer" science than physics, which means the same thing. Going softer, one can speak of sociology, the study of large groups of people. From a scientific point of view this is worse: not only are world's people out of the scientist's control, but their actions, demographics, characteristics, opinions, etc. change from year to year and even day to day. The only sort of repeatability a sociologist can hope for is by running two or more similar measurements/surveys/censuses at roughly the same time. Softer yet would be psychology/psychiatry, where one finds a few things which recur, like the addict's acquired physical dependence on drugs, or oedipal complexes, but these recurring elements occur in a multitude of variations unique to each subject and constitute only a small portion of the overall field of study.
Then there are many fields which are not properly science at all. Most of these have their roots decidedly outside of philosophy, and emphasize the practical or functional side of things: law, engineering, the arts, history, accounting, etc. These are often called professions. However there are at least three disciplines which are rooted in philosophy and therefore are not in the same class as the practical professions, but are not science either. One is philosophy itself, which has parted ways from natural philosophy by steering away from experiment. Another discipline is theology, which is rooted in philosophy and does emphasize very careful attention and thought about the world around us, but focuses on unrepeatable aspects of that world, namely persons and what they do, say, and write. If natural philosophy is the philosophy of repeatable things, theology is the philosophy of unrepeatable things, of persons. A third philosophical but non-scientific discipline is mathematics, which concerns certain results which can be reproduced on demand, but which are not part of the physical observable world.
Of course a lot of times there is a secret to repeating something; you have to figure out all the necessary preconditions. Finding out how to make something repeat can be part of hard science. For instance a few years ago someone reported observing a fusion reaction occurring fairly slowly, in smallish laboratory. Previously fusion had been observed only in the sun, thermonuclear bombs, and large experiments involving very large amounts of energy and heat, so the new observation was very exciting. Over the next years many many physicists spent a lot of time trying to make fusion happen in their own labs, using similar equipment. Some report that they found evidence for cold fusion, though their evidence was pretty subtle, the sort that requires very special measurement equipment, quite far from nuclear explosions. However many physicists failed entirely to reproduce cold fusion, and this happened so often that the scientific community as a whole remains sceptical of those who continue to report cold fusion in their labs. So here we see that the question - is cold fusion repeatable on demand? - is a valid question for physics. However as it became clear that many skilled researchers are unable to reproduce the original result, cold fusion moved out of the domain of hard science, and the physics community stopped thinking about it. If someday in the future someone did figure out a recipe for reproducing cold fusion on demand, then suddenly it would become again a physics question.
Then there are many fields which are not properly science at all. Most of these have their roots decidedly outside of philosophy, and emphasize the practical or functional side of things: law, engineering, the arts, history, accounting, etc. These are often called professions. However there are at least three disciplines which are rooted in philosophy and therefore are not in the same class as the practical professions, but are not science either. One is philosophy itself, which has parted ways from natural philosophy by steering away from experiment. Another discipline is theology, which is rooted in philosophy and does emphasize very careful attention and thought about the world around us, but focuses on unrepeatable aspects of that world, namely persons and what they do, say, and write. If natural philosophy is the philosophy of repeatable things, theology is the philosophy of unrepeatable things, of persons. A third philosophical but non-scientific discipline is mathematics, which concerns certain results which can be reproduced on demand, but which are not part of the physical observable world.
Of course a lot of times there is a secret to repeating something; you have to figure out all the necessary preconditions. Finding out how to make something repeat can be part of hard science. For instance a few years ago someone reported observing a fusion reaction occurring fairly slowly, in smallish laboratory. Previously fusion had been observed only in the sun, thermonuclear bombs, and large experiments involving very large amounts of energy and heat, so the new observation was very exciting. Over the next years many many physicists spent a lot of time trying to make fusion happen in their own labs, using similar equipment. Some report that they found evidence for cold fusion, though their evidence was pretty subtle, the sort that requires very special measurement equipment, quite far from nuclear explosions. However many physicists failed entirely to reproduce cold fusion, and this happened so often that the scientific community as a whole remains sceptical of those who continue to report cold fusion in their labs. So here we see that the question - is cold fusion repeatable on demand? - is a valid question for physics. However as it became clear that many skilled researchers are unable to reproduce the original result, cold fusion moved out of the domain of hard science, and the physics community stopped thinking about it. If someday in the future someone did figure out a recipe for reproducing cold fusion on demand, then suddenly it would become again a physics question.
Saturday, February 16, 2008
Experimental Verification - Summary
To sum up about scientific experiments, I think you have to really love the nature that you're trying to learn about and the tools that help you learn. Day to day it may not feel like love, and I don't know too many physicists who talk about being in love with nature, but the sort of attention and care given the experimental process, as well as the interest or even excitement about what is learned, is similar to the sort of attentiveness and long term dedication that one finds in certain loves between people. I choose to compare the experimental attitude to love between people rather than love for a skill or hobby, because a good experimentalist has his attention fixed on something outside of himself, rather than on his own activity. Also an experimentalist is deliberately interacting with something that may or may not do what he wants, that can surprise, that needs to be coaxed, and that is hard to understand. Unlike a profession there is no roadmap, instead one is somehow waiting on, listening, and even vulnerable.
Labels:
attention,
care,
collision with nature,
excitement,
interest,
love,
scientific experiment
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)